Sunset Hill

This Staten Island neighborhood is rapidly becoming one of the most popular destinations for living on the Island. It's no wonder: Located just south of West Brighton, Sunset Hill's reputation as one Staten Island's most affluent neighborhoods continues to grow, and its close proximity to parks and amenities makes it the perfect place to call home.

Staten Island

View Sunset Hill Homes For Sale

Sunset Hill Neighborhood Summary

On Sunset Hill's tree-lined, sun-dappled streets, you'll find an array of comfortable homes situated in a peaceful residential setting. Whether you're looking for modern touches or old-world style and charm, there's something for everyone at Sunset Hill. Homes for sale in the neighborhood include classic Colonials, contemporary split-levels, and roomy renovations, all waiting for you to turn the key and move right in.

Located in one of Staten Island's most beloved communities, Sunset Hill real estate can be surprisingly affordable. Houses are typically priced around $400,000 to start, increasing to more than $1,000,000. Nearly every home has 3 or 4 bedrooms, making the overall size of the homes a primary factor in pricing. Houses that sit around the $400k mark tend to be a little more than 1,000 sq. ft., while the most expensive homes sprawl over 3-4 times as much space. Regardless of size, any person would be lucky to call Sunset Hill "home".

Contact a Sunset Hill Real Estate Professional or Explore Sunset Hill Homes For Sale. Browse nearby neighborhoods below to continue your Staten Island real estate search!

Sunset Hill's Nearby Neighborhoods

Clove Lake Silver Lake West Brighton

Sunset Hill's Nearby Amenities

There's no better spot on the Island than Sunset Hill to enjoy the peacefulness of nature while still having ready access to everything you need. Situated north of the Staten Island Expressway and just a few blocks south of bustling Forest Avenue, Sunset Hill is nestled between Silver Lake Golf Course and Tennis Courts and verdant Clove Lakes Park, offering residents plenty of outdoor recreation opportunities. Additionally, it's close to Forest Avenue, where residents of the neighborhood and can shop for groceries, grab a cup of coffee, enjoy a leisurely lunch, or hit the gym for a workout. Victory Boulevard lies to the south for even more shopping and dining options, and the Staten Island Zoo is right next door.

Sunset Hill Schools

Sunset Hill is close to a number of public and private schools for K-12 students, as well as institutes of higher learning, such as Wagner College, St. John's University, and the College of Staten Island. For a map and more detailed information of schools you can find all across Staten Island, please visit our Local Schools page.

Transportation in Sunset Hill

No matter where you commute for work, Sunset Hill's convenience to public transportation continues to make the neighborhood an attractive option for those looking for real estate on Staten Island. Car commuters can use the Staten Island Expressway, accessible via Manor Road approximately 2 miles away. The St. George terminal on Bay Street is a short 10 minute drive from Sunset Hill and provides free and easy access to Manhattan via ferry, and numerous local bus routes stop on Forest Avenue, Victory Boulevard, and Clove Road. Additionally, there are numerous express buses to Brooklyn from the Island, making it simple for commuters to take their pick from a multitude of public transportation options available to them.

With its easy mix of charm and accessibility, set against a backdrop of nature and greenery, Sunset Hill has it all. The only thing missing is you.

Reach out to Tom Crimmins Realty today to schedule a home tour of Sunset Hill. Simply contact us via email or give us a call at 718.370.3200.

Sunset Hill Real Estate

Average Home Statistics
3 Beds
3 Baths
2,081 Sqft
1948 Built
Average Home Prices
Low $549k Avg $873k High $1.6M
Home Price / Sq. Ft
Low $329 Avg $448 High $628

Current Listings in Sunset Hill

18217h-a Spacious, Charming 3/4 Bedroom Brick C...

Photo of Listing #1118140

$725,000 Active

  • 4 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,370 ft²


93 Hartford Ave, Staten Island, NY

MLS® #1118140

18217h-a Spacious, Charming 3/4 Bedroom Brick Cape In Sunset Hill Boasting A New Kitchen, Ss Appliances, Updated Baths, Open Floor Plans W/hardwood Floors Throughout. Finished Basement, Separate Zoned, Family Room, Plenty Of Storage, Guest Suite. Private Ya...

Location, Location, Location! 3 Bedroom Coloni...

REDUCED 4% Photo of Listing #1118059

$649,000 Active

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,034 ft²


234 Hart Ave, Staten Island, NY

MLS® #1118059

Location, Location, Location! 3 Bedroom Colonial, On A Sought After Quiet Block In Sunset Hill. Old World Charm, Chestnut Trim, Hardwood Floors Throughout, Fireplace In Living Room, Large Dining Room, Plus A Sun Room. Walk Up Attic Is Fully Insulated With ...

Large, Detached Colonial With Open And Bright L...

Photo of Listing #1117897

$549,000 Active

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,080 ft²


146 Harvest Ave, Staten Island, NY

MLS® #1117897

Large, Detached Colonial With Open And Bright Layout, Located On A Tree Lined Street In The Heart Of Sunset Hill. Large Rooms With Formal Dining Room, And Family Room Off Kitchen Leading To Deck, Over-sized Backyard And Detached Garage. Hardwood Floors Unde...

Welcome To 16 Mathews Ave. This Broad Side Spli...

Photo of Listing #1117611

$869,000 Active

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 1,740 ft²


16 Mathews Ave, Staten Island, NY

MLS® #1117611

Welcome To 16 Mathews Ave. This Broad Side Split Level Architecturally Designed Mid Century Brick Ranch Is Nestled In Prestigious Sunset Hill. Enter Through The Custom Mahogany Doorway To A Fabulous Open Concept Featuring The Living Room, Dining Room And Mo...