Pleasant Plains

The neighborhood of Pleasant Plains in Staten Island's South Shore extends from Veterans Memorial Highway to the north and the Princes Bay shoreline to the south. Pleasant Plains is ideal for those who are looking to live close to both public transportation options and an open, more natural environment.

Staten Island

View Pleasant Plains Homes For Sale

Pleasant Plains Neighborhood Summary

Pleasant Plains is an upscale neighborhood with a real estate market that includes everything from stately homes on many acres to plenty of vacant land. Find out everything you need to know about finding a home in Pleasant Plains today.

History of Pleasant Plains

Thanks to the construction of the local train station when the SIR was extended to Tottenville during the mid-19th century, a community sprung up that was later called Pleasant Plains. As of the 2000 Census, the population of the neighborhood is around 5,000 residents. In the late 1800s, John Christopher Drumgoole purchased a large piece of land near Mount Loretto and built the Mission of the Immaculate Virgin at Mount Loretto, an orphanage with a farm that was once considered the biggest farm in all of New York State. One of Pleasant Plains' most recognizable landmarks is the Prince's Bay Lighthouse, which was built on the bluffs of Prince's Bay in 1864. While housing developments have sprung up in the neighborhood over the years, Pleasant Plains has maintained a sense of small-town living among oceanfront nature preserves.

Contact a Pleasant Plains Real Estate Professional or Explore Pleasant Plains Homes For Sale. Browse nearby neighborhoods below to continue your Staten Island real estate search!

Pleasant Plains' Nearby Neighborhoods

Prince's Bay Richmond Valley Woodrow

Pleasant Plains' Nearby Amenities

The epicenter of Pleasant Plains' retail shops and businesses is situated near the train station at the intersection of Bloomington Road and Amboy Road. The rest of the neighborhood is comprised small enclaves of residences interspersed with open space, wetlands, and park preserves. Those who love to hike, walk, or bicycle will appreciate the opportunities available for outdoor recreation in Pleasant Plains. The Dorothy Fitzpatrick Fishing Pier at the end of Sharrott Avenue is also a popular gathering spot not only for anglers, but those who enjoy the sea air and views. Nature lovers will enjoy exploring the Mt. Loretto Unique Area for its distinctive flora, fauna, and vistas. Both public and private schools serve the neighborhood, as well as preschools and daycare centers.

Pleasant Plains Schools

Pleasant Plains is close to a number of public and private schools for K-12 students, as well as institutes of higher learning, such as Wagner College, St. John's University, and the College of Staten Island. For a map, more detailed information, and reviews of schools you can find all across Staten Island, please visit our Local Schools page.

Transportation in Pleasant Plains

The Pleasant Plains train station is the hub of public transportation for the neighborhood. The train takes passengers to the St. George Ferry Terminal, where they then take the ferry over to Brooklyn. Drivers can access New Jersey easily via the Outerbridge Crossing in less than ten minutes from most points throughout the neighborhood. Express buses to Manhattan stop along Bloomingdale Road and Amboy Road.

Reach out to Tom Crimmins Realty today to schedule a home tour of Pleasant Plains. Simply contact us via email or give us a call at 718.370.3200.

Pleasant Plains Real Estate

Average Home Statistics
4 Beds
4 Baths
2,748 Sqft
1998 Built
Average Home Prices
Low $447k Avg $933k High $1.5M
Home Price / Sq. Ft
Low $175 Avg $366 High $886

Current Listings in Pleasant Plains

19317h: Gorgeous, Elegant, Inviting Describes T...

REDUCED 3% Photo of Listing #1130299

$1,549,900 Active

  • 5 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 4,000 ft²


14 Sarcona Ct, Staten Island, NY

MLS® #1130299

19317h: Gorgeous, Elegant, Inviting Describes This Beautiful All Brick Two Family Center Hall Colonial W/4 Bedrooms In Main Unit + 1 Bdrm Rental. Loaded W/custom Well Appointed Amenities & Quality Craftsmanship - This Home Is Designed To Impress! Features G...

New Construction. Impressive 2 Family Center Ha...

Photo of Listing #1133250

$1,499,900 Active

  • 4 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 3,600 ft²


26 Vail Ave, Staten Island, NY

MLS® #1133250

New Construction. Impressive 2 Family Center Hall Colonial Going Up Now! This Custom Dream Home Boasts Over 3600 Sq Ft On 1st And 2nd Floors Only! Oversized 50x160 Lot. Custom Pella Praire Style Double Doors Open To A Grand 2 Story Foyer With Stately O...

Location, Beauty & Fine Craftsmanship! This Cus...

Photo of Listing #1134246

$1,499,000 Active

  • 4 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • 4,080 ft²


38 South Drum St, Staten Island, NY

MLS® #1134246

Location, Beauty & Fine Craftsmanship! This Custom 4 Bedroom 6 Bathroom Center Hall Colonial (solid White Brick) Has Every Amenity A Buyer Could Want In A Home. The Last House On A Private Dead-end Street, This Masterpiece Sits On A 119x105 Lot And Features...

Style And Elegance Describe This Spacious Over ...

Photo of Listing #1132396

$1,429,000 Acceptance

  • 4 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 4,374 ft²


62 Petersons Ln, Staten Island, NY

MLS® #1132396

Style And Elegance Describe This Spacious Over 4000 Sq. Foot 2 Family Chcfeaturing 4 Bedrooms 4 Baths Over Sized Garage,radiant Heat,3 Zone Central A/c,4 Zone Heatresort Style Backyard And 1 Bedroom 2 Bath Duplex Apt. Level 1 Walk Up To Relaxing Wrap Aroun...