1686 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY

$4,350,000

Previous Next

5,978

Square feet

0.32

Acres

About 1686 Forest Avenue

PRIME FOREST AVENUE COMMERCIAL OPPORTUNITY — THIS WON'T LAST! An investment like this rarely becomes available—especially in such a coveted, high-exposure location. Situated directly on bustling Forest Avenue, just moments from the expressway and multiple major transit options, this meticulously cared-for five-unit commercial property offers exceptional visibility, consistent foot traffic, and unbeatable convenience. Set on an oversized lot, the building boasts ample on-site parking and a clean, maintenance-free exterior that enhances curb appeal and reduces operational costs. Long-standing, stable tenants occupy all five units, offering a strong and reliable income stream from day one. This is truly a turn-key investment for the savvy buyer looking to establish long-term equity and passive cash flow. Forest Avenue is one of the most heavily traveled commercial corridors in the region, making this location a standout for both tenants and future appreciation. Whether you're planning for early retirement, diversifying your portfolio, or securing a prime income-producing asset, this property delivers across the board. Location, location, location—this one truly cannot be beat. Please inquire within for financials and cap rate. Act fast—properties of this caliber and in this corridor are extremely rare and highly sought after.

Price History

Oct. 23, 2025 $4,350,000 (-300,000)
Aug. 27, 2025 $4,650,000 (-238,000)

Features of 1686 Forest Avenue

MLS® # 2504188
Price $4,350,000
Square Footage 5,978
Acres 0.32
Year Built 1932
Type Commercial Sale
Sub-Type Commercial
Status Active

Community Information

Address 1686 Forest Avenue
Area Westerleigh
City Staten Island
County Richmond
State NY
Zip Code 10302

Amenities

Has Pool No

Interior

Heating Steam, Natural Gas
Cooling Units
Fireplace No

Exterior

Exterior Frame
Construction Frame

Additional Information

Date Listed July 18th, 2025
Days on Market 104
Zoning R3-2
Foreclosure No
Short Sale No
RE / Bank Owned No

Listing Details

OfficeRobert DeFalco Realty, Inc.

Listing Map

Request a Showing

Provide a valid email address.
When would you like to view this property?