Posted by Tom Crimmins Realty on Tuesday, August 26th, 2025 11:59am.
Staten Island real estate continues to shine, and the latest coverage from Georgia Worrell of the New York Post highlights a trend that Tom Crimmins Realty has been seeing on the ground for years: more and more Brooklyn families are making Staten Island their new home.
In a recent article on borough migration patterns, the New York Post spotlighted Staten Island’s growing appeal to Brooklyn homebuyers. According to the report, 12% of Brooklyn homebuyers in 2025 chose Staten Island as their next stop — the highest borough-to-borough migration in the city.
Tom Crimmins himself was quoted, offering an insider’s perspective:
“People were in apartment buildings with no backyards and they couldn’t take vacations because of everything going on, so they moved to Staten Island for more space and privacy… and it just followed suit from there. People come to Staten Island and they stay, because they realize, ‘Wow, this is a really nice place.’ You’ve got great communities; beautiful, tree-lined streets — all for a great price.”
The article notes that Brooklyn’s median home price hovers around $850,000, while Staten Island’s sits closer to $708,000. For many families, that price difference can mean an extra bedroom, a backyard, or simply financial breathing room.
The pandemic reshaped buyer priorities. After months of lockdown in high-density apartments, Staten Island’s single-family homes, larger yards, and quieter neighborhoods became even more attractive. Unlike other boroughs, Staten Island offers suburban living without leaving the city.
While migration spiked during the pandemic, the report shows the trend hasn’t slowed. Brooklyn buyers made up 26% of Staten Island purchases in early 2020, and even in 2025 they still represent 21% — proof that Staten Island is no longer just a temporary fix, but a long-term solution.
The New York Post noted that much of the migration is concentrated from Brooklyn neighborhoods like Sunset Park, Bensonhurst, Borough Park, and Bay Ridge. These communities share cultural and family ties with Staten Island, making the transition feel familiar while still offering a fresh start.
At Tom Crimmins Realty, we see it every day: families arrive looking for more space and affordability, and end up falling in love with Staten Island’s strong sense of community, excellent schools, and parks. Many tell us the same thing — they can’t believe they didn’t consider it sooner.
Great Schools: Both public and private options rank among the best in the city.
Green Spaces: Staten Island is home to more parkland than any other borough, offering families room to breathe and explore.
Community Feel: From tree-lined streets to close-knit neighborhoods, Staten Island provides the sense of belonging many city residents crave.
Convenience: With bridge and ferry access, residents still enjoy easy connections to Manhattan, Brooklyn, and New Jersey.
Being featured in the New York Post is a proud moment for our brokerage — but it’s also a reminder of our mission. Staten Island isn’t just where we do business; it’s our home. Our team is made up of Staten Islanders who care deeply about helping families make the right move.
Whether you’re a Brooklyn buyer looking for more value, a Staten Islander ready to upgrade, or a first-time homebuyer exploring your options, Tom Crimmins Realty offers unmatched local expertise, decades of experience, and a commitment to honesty and transparency in every transaction.
If you’ve been thinking about a change, there has never been a better time to explore Staten Island. Reach out to Tom Crimmins Realty today and let us guide you through every step of the process.
Contact us today @ 718-370-3200 and discover why more New Yorkers are calling Staten Island home.